Harness vs. Collar: Which is Better for Your Dog?

What’s the difference between a harness and a collar?

A collar is a simple band that sits around a dog’s neck, commonly used for attaching ID tags and a leash. Collars are lightweight and quick to put on.

Harnesses, on the other hand, wrap around a dog’s body, with straps that distribute weight across the chest and shoulders. Different styles of harnesses give the owner a different level of control.

Pros and cons of collars

Collars work well for calm, well-trained dogs that don’t pull on their leash. They’re quick to use and comfortable for dogs without neck or respiratory issues. However, collars may not suit small or fragile dogs, or dogs with respiratory issues.

Pros

Ease of use
Collars are straightforward and easy to put on.

Identification and tags
Collars provide a designated spot for ID tags.

Good for calm dogs
For dogs that don’t pull or lunge on walks, collars can be a comfortable, unobtrusive option.

Cons

Risk of neck injury
Collars can put pressure on a dog’s neck and throat, which may lead to injuries, especially for dogs that pull or are prone to sudden lunges.

Not suitable for small breeds or brachycephalic dogs
Small dogs or breeds with delicate neck structures, such as Chihuahuas or Bulldogs, may be more prone to neck strain.

Potential behavioral issues
Dogs that pull against a collar can develop coughing or choking behaviors over time, making leash training harder.

ShawnCo’s Dream Walk Dog Collar is a great option if you’re seeking a collar that’s easy to use and provides comfort for all-day wear.

Pros and cons of harnesses

Harnesses are great for active dogs or those in training, as they distribute pressure across the chest. They’re ideal for small breeds and dogs with respiratory or neck concerns. However, some dogs find harnesses restrictive or uncomfortable.

Pros

Even pressure distribution
Harnesses distribute pulling pressure across the chest and back, which reduces strain on the neck.

Enhanced control
Harnesses offer better control over a dog’s movements, especially with front-clip options that naturally discourage pulling.

Training benefits
Many trainers recommend harnesses for leash training, as they allow dogs to move without restricting their breathing.

Cons

Potential discomfort
Some dogs initially find harnesses restrictive, particularly if they’re not used to wearing one.

Takes longer to put on
Unlike collars, harnesses generally require a bit more effort to put on and adjust.

Limited identification space
Many harnesses lack a designated area for ID tags, so owners might still need a collar for identification purposes.

Looking for a harness that discourages pulling behavior, but also easy to put on? ShawnCo’s Essential Dog Harness takes under 3 seconds to pull on and off.

How to choose which option is best for your dog

If you’re still debating between a collar and a harness, consider these factors.

Your dog’s size and breed
Large, strong dogs may benefit from the control of a harness, while smaller or more delicate breeds are often more comfortable in a harness to avoid neck strain.

Training needs
If your dog is still in training or tends to pull on the leash, a harness can help manage their movement without causing discomfort.

Health considerations
Dogs with respiratory issues, neck injuries, or delicate tracheas might find harnesses gentler on their bodies.

Lifestyle and activities
If you frequently take your dog on short walks or quick outings, a collar may be more convenient. For longer or more active outings, a harness can provide better support and control.